Why did India ban TikTok?

What Lessons Does It Hold for the Product Managers?

Key Highlights

  • 200 Million Users Lost: Sensor Tower data reveals a staggering loss of over 200 million monthly active users for TikTok, a significant chunk of its global audience.

  • Data Security Woes: A 2020 PIB press release highlights the Indian government's primary concern: data security. With no public data on how much user information was collected or where it was stored, the trust deficit remains high.

  • Local Innovation Thrives: The ban spurred a surge in Indian short-form video apps. Platforms like MX, and TakaTak cater to regional languages and cultural nuances, offering a familiar user experience that resonates with a domestic audience.

  • Government Support: The Indian government has shown support for these homegrown apps, potentially viewing them as a way to boost domestic tech and reduce reliance on foreign platforms.

  • A chance to make a comeback? Read on to know…

Founding Tale of TikTok

Source: The Verge

From News to Short-Form Videos: ByteDance's Vision

The story of TikTok begins in 2012 with ByteDance, a Chinese tech company founded by Zhang Yiming. Zhang, with a background in engineering, saw a future where users would consume information differently, particularly on mobile devices.

Zhang Yiming Source: Forbes

ByteDance's initial focus was on news aggregation, developing an app called Toutiao that used AI algorithms to personalize news feeds for users. This focus on user experience and content recommendation would become a hallmark of TikTok as well.

Douyin's Rise in China: The Power of Short Videos

In September 2016, ByteDance launched Douyin in China. Douyin offered a unique proposition: a platform for creating and sharing short-form videos. While Vine, another short-form video platform, was popular globally at the time, it was being phased out.

Douyin App, Source China Gravy

Douyin capitalized on this gap, offering easy-to-use editing tools, music integration, and special effects. This combination resonated with millennial audiences in China, leading to Douyin's rapid rise.

Going Global with TikTok: A New Platform is Born

Recognizing Douyin's potential for a global audience, ByteDance launched TikTok in September 2017 specifically for international markets.

While similar to Douyin in functionality, TikTok catered to international music trends and cultural nuances. This strategic move allowed TikTok to capture the short-form video craze outside of China.

Musical.ly Acquisition: Merging Strengths for Global Domination

In November 2017, ByteDance made a strategic move by acquiring Musical.ly, a popular US-based short-form video app. Musical.ly had a strong user base, particularly in North America and Europe, and was known for its focus on lip-syncing and music-driven content.

Musical.ly, Source: Business Insider

This acquisition allowed TikTok to merge its own strengths with Musical.ly's established user base and content focus, solidifying its position as a major player in the global short-form video market.

Merging Forward: TikTok's Global Domination

By August 2018, ByteDance fully merged TikTok with Musical.ly, consolidating user bases and content under the TikTok brand.

This move eliminated redundancy and allowed TikTok to leverage its now-global user base and content creation trends to further propel its growth.

Zhang Yiming's Vision: A Foundation for Success

While ByteDance provided the platform and resources, Zhang Yiming's vision for creating a user-friendly and engaging platform for short-form video creation and sharing is considered the foundation of TikTok's success story.

His focus on user experience, content recommendation algorithms, and a global approach all played a crucial role in TikTok's meteoric rise to become a dominant social media platform.

Data on TikTok's Popularity Before the Ban

Massive User Base

According to Sensor Tower, a mobile app analytics firm, TikTok had over 200 million users in India before the ban. This translates to roughly 1/6th of its global user base at the time.

Top Downloaded App

Data from App Annie, another mobile app analytics company, indicates that TikTok was the most downloaded app in India in 2020, surpassing established players like WhatsApp and Facebook.

Indian Government Statements Regarding TikTok Ban

Here's a more detailed look at the Indian government's statements on the TikTok ban, incorporating the information you provided:

Press Release (June 2020)

  • Focus on Data Security and Privacy: The Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) likely emphasized concerns about data security and privacy in their press release. They might have mentioned specific anxieties, such as:

    • The potential for user data (location, browsing habits, personal details) to be collected and transferred outside of India.

    • The lack of transparency regarding data storage locations and how user data is used by ByteDance (TikTok's parent company).

    • The possibility of the Chinese government accessing user data due to national security laws in China.

  • National Security Concerns: While not explicitly mentioned in the excerpt, the press release might have alluded to broader national security concerns. This could involve:

    • The potential for the platform to be used for propaganda or misinformation campaigns.

    • Risks of censorship of content critical of China.

    • National security threats if user data falls into the wrong hands.

Parliamentary Address (July 2020)

Minister Dhotre's Statement: Minister of State Sanjay Dhotre's statement in Parliament likely elaborated on the data security concerns. He might have mentioned:

  • The vast amount of data collected by TikTok and the potential risks associated with it.

  • The possibility of "data on our citizens going into the wrong hands" highlights the concern of unauthorized access or misuse of user data.

  • The lack of control the Indian government had over data practices on a platform owned by a Chinese company.

TikTok’s Failure Reasons in India

Security Concerns

Here's an expanded explanation of the security concerns surrounding TikTok that led to the ban in India:

Data Security and Geopolitical Tensions

  • User Data Collection: At the heart of the Indian government's concerns lies the vast amount of user data collected by TikTok, including browsing habits, location information, and personal details.

  • Data Sharing with China: Given ByteDance's ownership and its location in China, the Indian government expressed apprehension about user data potentially being shared with the Chinese government. This concern is heightened due to strained political relations between India and China.

  • Lack of Transparency: Concerns were also raised about the lack of transparency regarding data storage locations and how user data is used by ByteDance. This lack of clarity fueled suspicion about potential government access.

Potential National Security Risks

  • Censorship and Propaganda: The Indian government worried that the Chinese government could influence content moderation on TikTok, potentially censoring content critical of China or promoting pro-China propaganda.

  • Espionage and Surveillance: There were also concerns that user data, including location information, could be used for espionage or surveillance purposes by the Chinese government.

Measures Taken by TikTok

  • Data Localization: In an attempt to address these concerns, TikTok assured the Indian government that user data was stored on servers in Singapore and the United States, not China.

  • Compliance with Indian Laws: TikTok also claimed to comply with all Indian data privacy regulations.

This is what the Head of TikTok India, Nikhil Gandhi posted on Twitter soon after the ban:

Source: bbc.co.uk

However, these assurances weren't enough to satisfy the Indian government's concerns, leading to the ban.

Content Regulation

Here's an expanded explanation of the content regulation concerns surrounding TikTok that contributed to the ban in India:

Challenges of Moderating Diverse Content

  • Misinformation and Fake News: India has a well-documented problem with the spread of misinformation and fake news online, often with serious consequences.

    The Indian government worried that TikTok's algorithm, focused on virality and short snippets, could be easily exploited to spread false information.

  • Potentially Offensive Content: Indian society has strong social and cultural norms.

    The government expressed concern about the potential for offensive or objectionable content, including religious or political slurs, to spread on the platform due to the difficulty of effectively moderating a vast amount of user-generated content.

Difficulties with Effective Moderation

  • Volume of Content: The sheer volume of content uploaded daily on TikTok makes it challenging for any platform to effectively moderate everything. This is especially true for short-form video formats where potentially harmful content can be disguised or delivered quickly.

  • Algorithmic Bias: Concerns existed that TikTok's algorithm might inadvertently amplify certain types of content, like misinformation or offensive material, over others due to factors like user engagement or watch time.

  • Language Barrier: India has a multitude of languages and dialects. Effectively moderating content across all these languages would require a massive team of moderators with deep cultural understanding, which can be a logistical challenge for any platform.

India's Strict Stance on Online Content

  • History of Online Mob Violence: India has witnessed several instances of online mobs targeting individuals based on misinformation or rumors spread online. The government aimed to curb the spread of such harmful content through stricter online regulation.

  • Existing Legal Framework: India has legal frameworks like the Information Technology Act (2000) that give the government power to take down content deemed objectionable or threatening national security. Banning TikTok was seen as a way to exert greater control over online content.

Efforts by TikTok

  • Content Moderation Team: TikTok maintained a team of moderators specifically focused on the Indian market to review and remove flagged content.

  • Community Guidelines: The platform also had community guidelines outlining prohibited content.

However, the Indian government felt these measures were insufficient to address the challenges of effectively moderating such a vast platform.

Rise of Domestic Video-Sharing Apps: A Challenge for TikTok's Return

The ban on TikTok in India created a gap in the short-form video-sharing market. This gap has been filled by the emergence of several domestic Indian apps, which have gained significant popularity.

This new landscape posed a hurdle for TikTok's potential return to India. Here's a deeper look at this factor:

Popularity of Domestic Alternatives

  • MX, TakaTak and Moj: These are two of the most prominent Indian short-form video sharing apps that have seen a surge in users since the TikTok ban. They offer similar features to TikTok, including video creation tools, music integration, and special effects.

  • Catering to Local Preferences: These domestic apps often cater specifically to Indian audiences. They might prioritize regional languages, incorporate popular Indian music and trends, and feature content creators familiar with Indian culture.

  • Government Support: The Indian government has been supportive of these domestic platforms, potentially viewing them as a way to promote Indian tech companies and reduce reliance on foreign platforms.

Challenges for TikTok's Return

  • Established User Base: MX TakaTak and Moj have already established a loyal user base. Users accustomed to these platforms might be hesitant to switch back to TikTok, especially if the domestic apps continue to offer a familiar and engaging experience.

  • Content Creator Ecosystem: A thriving ecosystem of content creators has emerged on these domestic platforms. These creators might be reluctant to move back to TikTok if they've already established themselves and gained a following on Indian apps.

  • Government Scrutiny: The Indian government might be wary of allowing TikTok back if it disrupts the success story of these domestic platforms. They might prioritize supporting homegrown businesses and potentially impose stricter regulations on TikTok if it's allowed to return.

However, this doesn't necessarily mean a permanent ban on TikTok. Here are some possibilities:

  • Finding a Niche: If TikTok can demonstrate a unique value proposition that complements rather than competes with domestic apps, it might find a place in the Indian market. This could involve focusing on a specific niche audience or genre of content.

  • Collaboration with Domestic Players: A potential collaboration with Indian companies for data storage, content moderation, or even content creation could be explored by TikTok to address security concerns and gain a foothold in the market.

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to allow TikTok back in India rests with the government. They will weigh the potential benefits of a global platform against the potential risks and the success of domestic alternatives.

Thank U Reaction GIF by Mauro Gatti

Join the conversation

or to participate.